|
Post by dindsenchas on Jun 10, 2020 20:40:14 GMT
Peterson is essentially a product of Protestant Christianity, with a multi-faith tradition dating back to Jung. He's identified himself as a classic liberal and is an ardent critic of the modern left: www.jordanbpeterson.com/political-correctness/equity-when-the-left-goes-too-far/. However, he has been criticised by past colleagues for being power-hungry: www.thestar.com/opinion/2018/05/25/i-was-jordan-petersons-strongest-supporter-now-i-think-hes-dangerous.htmlHis religious work is in the vein of Carl Jung and Joseph Campbell comparative religion. Religion is seen from a narrative perspective, hypothesising that it represents key aspects of human experience and meaning making across all environments. However, Peterson has been criticised as being vague on his own beliefs, stating that he behaves "as if" God exists. He did a debating tour which passed through Ireland, debating Sam Harris in support of the existence of God and the meaning of the biblical stories. But he's cagey on the specifics of God's influence on Earth, miracles, prayer, attending church, etc. Presumably, from the conservative perspective, any criticism of the left is welcome. Especially in the context of the current American campus wars. How does his work comport with your religious views? My assumption is that people are Catholics on here, could be wrong. Has the Pope ever mentioned him? Or anyone else high up?
|
|
|
Post by assisi on Jun 10, 2020 21:17:57 GMT
Peterson is essentially a product of Protestant Christianity, with a multi-faith tradition dating back to Jung. He's identified himself as a classic liberal and is an ardent critic of the modern left: www.jordanbpeterson.com/political-correctness/equity-when-the-left-goes-too-far/. However, he has been criticised by past colleagues for being power-hungry: www.thestar.com/opinion/2018/05/25/i-was-jordan-petersons-strongest-supporter-now-i-think-hes-dangerous.htmlHis religious work is in the vein of Carl Jung and Joseph Campbell comparative religion. Religion is seen from a narrative perspective, hypothesising that it represents key aspects of human experience and meaning making across all environments. However, Peterson has been criticised as being vague on his own beliefs, stating that he behaves "as if" God exists. He did a debating tour which passed through Ireland, debating Sam Harris in support of the existence of God and the meaning of the biblical stories. But he's cagey on the specifics of God's influence on Earth, miracles, prayer, attending church, etc. Presumably, from the conservative perspective, any criticism of the left is welcome. Especially in the context of the current American campus wars. How does his work comport with your religious views? My assumption is that people are Catholics on here, could be wrong. Has the Pope ever mentioned him? Or anyone else high up? Here's a thread referring to JP a while ago. See what you think of it: irishconservative.freeforums.net/thread/444/jordan-peterson
|
|
|
Post by cato on Jun 11, 2020 21:43:28 GMT
How does his work comport with your religious views? My assumption is that people are Catholics on here, could be wrong. Has the Pope ever mentioned him? Or anyone else high up? [/quote]
I doubt Pope Francis would be a fan of Dr Peterson but the pope is somewhat outspokenly opposed to gender ideology which gives them something in common.
|
|
|
Post by cato on Jul 1, 2020 19:46:17 GMT
On a purely anecdotal basis I know 3 people disillusioned with the current cultural madness who would traditionally have been seen as broadly liberal left in outlook.
They are now avid Peterson fans and find his critique of our woes a great source of wisdom and indeed hope. Sadly few mainstream political or religious leaders are offering any persuasive analysis or answers.
|
|
|
Post by Tomas on Oct 25, 2020 11:22:39 GMT
Peterson is essentially a product of Protestant Christianity, with a multi-faith tradition in the vein of Carl Jung and Joseph Campbell comparative religion. However, Peterson has been criticised as being vague on his own beliefs, he's cagey on the specifics of God's influence on Earth, miracles, prayer, attending church, etc. How does his work comport with your religious views? Has the Pope ever mentioned him? Or anyone else high up?Failing to answer either yes no or indifferent so try to answer here as a resort: I think and "feel" his social criticism has been helpful to some extent, while at the same time morally irrelevant on a wider scale. Thus *better than nothing* but not worth too serious attention, to be blunt (strong emphasis on the word too there before serious attention). His hype were of a similar kind as that for Richard Dawkins. For that reason alone it would have been highly inappropiate for Church hierarchy to lift up any personal mention in official speech. It gets paradoxically off the problem to put in any answer to the poll since the impression is a veritable mix of all three. Each answer could be taken in with an added motivation line, yet none add up to the reason of making one culturally flawed hype sustained. Sorry if this sounds only negative, perhaps that goes for most of the things I´m writing here. Conservatism and the true Religion simply holds water in a way that this kind of secular moralism never could do.
|
|